AdminThe Old Firm match between Rangers and Celtic is always a highly anticipated and intense affair, with both teams vying for bragging rights and supremacy in Scottish football. The latest installment of this rivalry took place on Thursday, with Rangers emerging victorious with a convincing 3-0 win over their arch-rivals. However, the match was not without controversy, as a incident involving Rangers left-back Jefte and Celtic winger Nicolas Kuhn sparked a heated debate about the use of VAR in Scottish football.
The incident in question occurred in the first half of the match, when Jefte caught Kuhn with a swinging elbow, leaving the Celtic player with a bloody nose. The referee, Don Robertson, was quick to intervene and showed Jefte a yellow card for the foul. However, former Celtic defender Mark Wilson believes that the referee should have taken a closer look at the incident and considered issuing a red card to Jefte.
Wilson, who was analyzing the match for Open Goal, stated, “I’ve got to say, that was as blatant a red card as you’ll see. Was there proper force behind it? How can it not be if it bursts his nose. I think if you’re booking him for that and thinking it’s not accidental… I think it’s a red card all day long.” Wilson’s comments suggest that he believes Jefte’s actions were intentional and warranted a more severe punishment than a yellow card.
However, not everyone agrees with Wilson’s assessment. Former top-flight referee Des Roache, who was analyzing the match for Record Sport, believes that Jefte’s action was not intentional, but rather reckless and dangerous. Roache stated, “It’s not a deliberate action. He’s actually using his arm to balance, but he has caught him. So therefore it’s reckless and dangerous rather than serious foul play or violent conduct. So I’m okay with the yellow for that.”
The Scottish Football Association’s (SFA) Key Match Incident panel also backed the referee’s decision, stating that the caution served to Jefte was “unanimously supported” by the panel. The panel’s decision suggests that they believe the referee made the correct call in issuing a yellow card to Jefte, and that the incident did not warrant a red card.
Despite the SFA’s backing, Wilson remains convinced that Jefte should have been sent off, and that the referee’s decision was a lucky break for Rangers. Wilson’s comments have sparked a debate about the use of VAR in Scottish football, with some arguing that the technology is not being used effectively to review incidents like this. The debate has also raised questions about the consistency of refereeing decisions in Scottish football, and whether the use of VAR is helping to improve the accuracy of these decisions.
The incident has also highlighted the challenges of refereeing in high-pressure matches like the Old Firm derby. Referees are often under intense scrutiny, and their decisions can have a significant impact on the outcome of the match. In this case, the referee’s decision to issue a yellow card to Jefte rather than a red card has been questioned by some, and it will be interesting to see how the SFA and the Scottish Professional Football League (SPFL) respond to the controversy.
In the end, the result of the match was not affected by the incident, as Rangers went on to win comfortably. However, the controversy surrounding Jefte’s elbow has added an extra layer of drama to the already intense Old Firm rivalry. As the two teams prepare to face each other again in the future, it will be interesting to see how the referees and VAR officials handle similar incidents, and whether the SFA and SPFL take any steps to address the concerns raised by Wilson and others.
The use of VAR in Scottish football is still a relatively new development, and it is clear that there are still some teething problems to be ironed out. However, the technology has the potential to improve the accuracy of refereeing decisions and reduce controversy in matches. As the SFA and SPFL continue to develop and refine the use of VAR, it will be interesting to see how it impacts the game and whether it helps to reduce the kind of controversy that surrounded Jefte’s elbow.
In conclusion, the incident involving Jefte and Kuhn has sparked a heated debate about the use of VAR in Scottish football, and has raised questions about the consistency of refereeing decisions. While the SFA and SPFL have backed the referee’s decision, Wilson and others remain convinced that Jefte should have been sent off. As the Old Firm rivalry continues to simmer, it will be interesting to see how the referees and VAR officials handle similar incidents in the future, and whether the SFA and SPFL take any steps to address the concerns raised by Wilson and others.
Admin
