AdminCollingwood Secures Jack Silvagni from Carlton in $2.2 Million Deal
In one of the most talked-about AFL moves of the season, Collingwood Football Club has confirmed the signing of Jack Silvagni from the Carlton Football Club in a deal worth $2.2 million over two years. The announcement, made official on Thursday morning, ends weeks of speculation surrounding Silvagni’s future and marks a significant shift in the landscape of Victorian football.
The two-year deal will see Silvagni don the black and white until at least the end of the 2027 season. The 26-year-old forward and utility player departs Carlton after playing 136 games over nine seasons, carrying not only his own reputation but also the weight of one of football’s most storied family legacies.
“It’s a new chapter and a big decision, but I feel ready,” Silvagni said in a statement released by Collingwood. “Collingwood presented an exciting vision, and I’m thrilled to be part of a club with such a strong identity, a winning culture, and a passionate supporter base. I’m grateful to Carlton for everything, but I’m looking forward to what lies ahead.”
A Shocking but Strategic Switch
The signing has raised eyebrows across the AFL community, not just for its financial weight — approximately $1.1 million per year — but also because of the deep-rooted rivalry between Collingwood and Carlton. Jack Silvagni, the son of Carlton great Stephen Silvagni and grandson of club legend Sergio Silvagni, was long viewed as a “Blue for life.” His unexpected departure has sparked both surprise and debate among fans and commentators.
Despite emotional ties to his former club, insiders suggest the move was driven by a mix of career opportunity, role clarity, and contract security — something Collingwood was quick to offer.
“Jack is a player of great character and versatility,” said Collingwood GM of Football Graham Wright. “He brings experience, leadership, and a team-first mentality. We believe he fits perfectly into our system and complements our long-term goals.”
Silvagni is expected to play a hybrid role at the Pies — rotating between forward, wing, and even the occasional defensive matchup — depending on team structure and injury coverage. His contested marking, footy IQ, and ability to adapt have long been admired, even when his form fluctuated at Carlton.
Carlton Pays Tribute
Carlton Football Club released a measured and respectful statement, acknowledging Silvagni’s contribution to the club and the emotional weight of his departure.
“Jack has carried the Silvagni name with integrity and pride,” said Carlton CEO Brian Cook. “We thank him for his commitment to the navy blue over many years and understand his decision to pursue a new opportunity. He leaves with our respect and best wishes.”
Despite a tumultuous 2023 season marred by injury and inconsistent selection, Silvagni remained a fan favorite at Carlton. Known for his effort, selflessness, and passion for the jumper, his departure leaves a symbolic gap as well as a tactical one.
Reactions Mixed but Passionate
Unsurprisingly, the reaction among supporters has been mixed — ranging from disappointment and heartbreak among the Carlton faithful to enthusiasm and intrigue from the Magpie army.
Social media platforms lit up within minutes of the announcement, with some Carlton fans expressing frustration at the club’s inability to retain a player so deeply connected to its identity, while Collingwood fans welcomed the move as a savvy and bold acquisition.
“He’s got a point to prove,” said one Collingwood supporter on X (formerly Twitter). “We love players with something to prove.”
AFL great Garry Lyon commented on SEN Radio: “It’s going to be strange seeing Jack in black and white, no doubt about that. But credit to him for stepping out of the shadow and taking control of his career. This move could really reignite his footy.”
A Fresh Start in Black and White
For Silvagni, the move represents a fresh start and a chance to redefine himself outside the long shadow of his family’s legacy. With Collingwood currently contending at the top of the ladder and boasting one of the most dynamic young lists in the competition, the timing couldn’t be better.
The club has recently lost a few senior players to retirement and free agency, and Silvagni’s experience and maturity could fill an important leadership void both on and off the field.
“I’m not here just to wear the jumper,” Silvagni added. “I want to contribute to success, to earn my spot, and to help Collingwood go even further. I know it’ll take hard work, but that’s what I’m here for.”
As the AFL world processes one of the most symbolic transfers in recent memory, all eyes will now turn to pre-season training — and Round 1 of 2026, when Silvagni could face his former club in what promises to be a blockbuster showdown.
Admin
