The Baltimore Orioles’ decision to lock up Samuel Basallo with an eight-year, $67 million extension, potentially rising to $88.5 million, is expected to reshape the catcher market across Major League Baseball. With Basallo established as Baltimore’s long-term backstop, the Orioles are now positioned to make Adley Rutschman — once their cornerstone player — available.

If Baltimore follows through, the Cincinnati Reds are widely expected to act swiftly, with reports indicating they are preparing to complete a blockbuster deal for Rutschman. Such a move would instantly become one of the boldest midseason acquisitions in recent Reds history, signaling a willingness to take risks while other playoff-contending teams might favor stability.

Betting Big on a Former Star

Rutschman, the 2019 No. 1 overall pick, was once considered untouchable. Between 2022 and 2023, he emerged as one of the league’s brightest talents, delivering strong offensive production while excelling behind the plate. Though his numbers have dipped since 2024, his defensive leadership and ability to manage a pitching staff remain elite. The Reds believe that in a hitter-friendly environment like Great American Ball Park, Rutschman could rediscover his All-Star form.

Why the Reds Are Moving Fast

The deal, if finalized, would surprise many who expected Cincinnati to stay focused on its current playoff chase. With Jose Trevino and Tyler Stephenson already in the mix, and top prospect Alfredo Duno waiting in the wings, the catching depth chart is far from bare. Still, Cincinnati’s front office appears determined to secure Rutschman not just for the present, but as a cornerstone for the franchise’s next era.

A Defining Gamble Ahead

Should the trade go through, the Reds will likely part with a substantial package of prospects and young talent. That gamble could pay off massively if Rutschman rebounds, but it also carries long-term risk. Yet, for a team often criticized for being too cautious, this would mark a decisive shift — a statement that Cincinnati is no longer content to wait on the future, but is ready to reshape it.

As negotiations develop, all eyes are set to be on Rutschman. If the Reds complete the move and he regains his form, it could redefine the trajectory of the franchise and go down as one of the defining trades in club history.