AdminWhen the Cincinnati Reds made the decision to bring in Ke’Bryan Hayes at the trade deadline, the reaction around baseball was consistent. The move was praised for giving the Reds one of the best gloves in the game at third base. Beyond his stellar defense, however, expectations were tempered. Hayes had long been considered an elite fielder whose bat often failed to measure up, and few believed he would be anything more than a defensive boost for a club fighting for consistency in the National League Central race.
Those doubts were understandable. Hayes was coming off a disastrous 2024 season with the Pittsburgh Pirates, slashing a meager .233/.283/.290 with only four home runs across 96 games. Even the start of his 2025 season showed no signs of an offensive resurgence, with his numbers looking just as stagnant. To most observers—and perhaps even to the Reds’ own front office—Hayes seemed locked into the label of a one-dimensional player.
But sometimes, a change of scenery rewrites the story.
Since arriving in Cincinnati, Hayes has completely flipped the script, giving the Reds an offensive spark no one predicted. In just 20 games, he has already matched the home run total he produced in 100 games earlier this season with Pittsburgh. His slash line of .266/.319/.469 as a Red is not only a massive improvement from his Pirates numbers but also a reminder of his 2023 breakout season, when he hit 15 home runs, drove in 61 RBIs, and batted .271 across 124 games.
The analytics reinforce what the eye test shows. Hayes has posted a 110 OPS+ since the trade—his best offensive mark since his electrifying rookie cameo in 2020, when he produced a staggering 201 OPS+ in just 24 games. Suddenly, Cincinnati has discovered reliability and production from a position that was previously one of the weakest on their roster.
Before the trade deadline, Reds third basemen collectively ranked 21st in MLB in batting average (.234) and just 18th in RBIs. Since Hayes joined the team, that ranking has skyrocketed to fourth in average (.289) and sixth in RBIs (17). His impact has been undeniable, with teammate Noelvi Marte also benefiting from the stability Hayes has brought to the hot corner.
The Reds pursued Hayes primarily for his defensive reputation, but what they’ve received is a two-way difference-maker. His glove remains gold-standard, but his bat has turned into a surprise weapon. If Hayes sustains even a fraction of this offensive production down the stretch, this acquisition will not just be a tidy piece of business—it could become one of the most underappreciated steals of the entire 2025 trade deadline.
For a Reds team clawing for playoff relevance, Hayes’ resurgence could not have come at a better time. What once seemed like a move for defensive insurance has turned into a game-changing addition, reshaping both their lineup and their postseason hopes.
Admin
